DR ALI SINA EXPOSED

From: Truth teller
Date: 01 Mar 2001
Time: 11:32:08
Remote Name: 195.92.67.71

Comments

Dr Ali Sina is a fraud! - he is an iranian right and therefore a shia - why then is he quoting from SUNNI hadith books like Bukhari and Abu Dawud which Shia utterly reject as false!! - if he grew up in iran as he claims or was taught islam by shia he never would have been taught from these books - they are not available- why doesnt he quote from Al-Kafi or shia hadith books/texts??? - he takes from a translation of the quran by a wahaabi Dr Muhsin Khan - no shia would do this -wahabbi hate shia and think they are kafir!!! - the translations of bukhari and muhsin khan quran are readily available in the west - so what this kaffir has done is read them and then pretend to be a muslim - but he gets it completely wrong!!!

When he says "I could not believe what i read in bukhari" he is correct - since no shia believes what is in bukhari is correct!!!

He narrates hadith from people who shias consider to be untrusthworthy like Aisha - so how can this be a true hadith?? Also many of the hadith in Bukhari and Abu Dawud are considered weak by many later SUNNI scholars!! - how does he know he is not quoting a weak or forged hadith?????

He narrates hadith from Umar!! - Shias HATE and curse Umar - he quotes hadith from Abu Huraira - shiites reject ALL his hadith - he was a supporter of Muawiya!!

He says islam demands blind faith - but there are over 60 verses telling us to use our reason- if he is an islamic expert why doesnt he know this!!

He makes terrible basic mistakes in his work that only a non-muslim or an amazingly ignorant muslim could make - Maria was not Hafsa's maidsrvant!! The Prophet never was married to 20 wives, his wives were not all young except 2 as he claims quite the opposite!! His wifes uncle was not called Abu Nifel but waraqa

Also his name is false - I have never met a persian with the surname "Sina" - what the non-Muslim who wrote this has done is take the first and last names from the name of the great persian scientist Abu Ali al-Husain ibn Abdallah ibn Sina (Avicenna) - but they do not know that sina is not ever used as a surname - it was ibn sina (son of sina's) fathers name - what arabs call kunya!! - ibn sina was also known as a freethinker as ali sina wishes to be known - excpet he had the brains to cover he tracks and not make so many glaring mistakes!!!

He also cannot make up his mind - one minute he is called the Prophet a Prophet and writing (pbuh) peace be upon him after his name - the next line he is slandering and calling him a fraud and a murderer!!!

I have met many Muslims who say bad things about islam, that it is backward etc, and dont follow it - but they would never use such foul language about the Prophet (pbuh)

It is interesting that some of his arguments (such as muslims only proof that islam is true is based on having 1 billion followers) are exact replicates of what hindu polemists against islam say

Last changed: August 29, 2006

Great work

From: Chicago
Date: 29 Aug 2006
Time: 02:27:01
Remote Name: 125.182.71.26

Comments